Repped Artists:

Siya Oum MTG Chandra 3 Cover Auction Lots including Controversy Cover and FIRST Tibalt!

July 24, 2019

Magic the Gathering Chandra #3 - Siya Oum Cover Art (3 lots including controversy cover and final printed cover)

Currently available via auction ending Wednesday July 31 (being run on MTG Art Market on Facebook but you can also bid directly to [email protected] and the prices will be kept updated on the TDArt News Page under the current news). The photos below and scans will also be posted on the #tdart site under Siya's art shortly.

Current Bids:

Lot A –  SOLD

Lot B – SOLD

Lot C – unsold, will be posted for sale directly on site

Please bid in $25 or larger increments in whole dollar amounts.

Details on the art and story behind the controversy:

Up for auction we have three lots in relation to Siya Oum’s cover art for Chandra #3.

IDW publishes the official MTG comics and these stories are canon with the MTG universe. This is also the first time we’re seeing Tibalt published (on a cover) and all his MTG card art has been digital.

Part of the reason I’m auctioning these lots is because of the story behind the art. As some of you may know, when the art was shown for Previews (the comic book catalog), there was an online explosion of upset fans. Many felt that the image of Tibalt standing over Chandra was against the direction WotC is moving with MTG characters and lore. The cover ended up with edits then getting completely redone (see details below). Check out a couple of the videos here:



The art is being sold in three separate lots:

Lot A – The outrage lot: This lot includes the original pencils (left) and the original inks on bluelines (right). The inked blueline is what was used as the art that was sent to previews. This is the art that sparked a big debate online. When IDW sent over the cover idea to Siya, they gave some ideas on layouts and she did several thumbnails. This was the image that was chosen by WotC for the cover. Siya did the art and made corrections and it was exactly what they asked for and it was sent off to Previews. Once the image hit the catalog there was a lot of chatter about Tibalt being introduced, but also about many fans distaste with the choices on the cover. IDW contacted back shortly thereafter that WotC wanted some adjustments made to the cover to make Chandra appear less defeated. You may see in the pencils that Chandra’s face is just ever so slightly changed to make her look more mad. But after a bit of talking it was decided they wanted more changes, which leads us to

Lot B – The redraw lot: This lot is the redraws of the original concept and includes the completed inks on the left, the approved sketch in the middle (this one is on thin copy paper), then some corrections on the right including a small copy paper with blueline printout and inked tail corrections and a half penciled page with character and tail correction. This was the second pass at the cover with changes made to help change the feel behind the cover. Unfortunately, even with all the corrections, it ended up being decided to scrap the whole idea and go to

Lot C – The published art lot: It was eventually decided they wanted the entire previous idea scrapped and one of the other layouts was chosen and a whole new cover was drawn. This lot includes the completed cover (pencils and inks) with a printed copy of the pencils and a printed copy of the approved layouts.

First 3 photos are of the lots so you can see what is in each then scans of each item are included afterwards

The book is released this week and can be found at your local comic shop.

[]( this is still showing the originally solicited cover. If you click the Previews Prevue (scroll down past the book price) you’ll see the final cover.

Auction begins now, Wednesday July 24 and ends Wednesday July 31 at 7 pm PST (Pacific time- San Francisco)

Any bids on an item in the last 10 minutes will extend the auction time by 5 minutes. You may place bids publicly on the Facebook thread or via email. Keep in mind if we aren’t yet Facebook friends that your messages to me may get put into a request folder and I may not see it right away, so I recommend sending any messages before the end of the auction and/or friending me.

Payment plans are accepted if needed (please inquire to discuss terms) and auction follows all TDArt sales terms.

Please feel free to send over any questions you may have.

p.s she did do one other cover for them which will be sold at a later date once the book is out.
Lot A, the controversy lot (see details at top of newsletter and below for scans)
Lot B (version 2) - see details on top of this newsletter and see below for scans 
Lot C, final image used for cover (see details above and scans below)
Please be sure to check out the website www.TDArtGallery.comregularly for updates, and for up to the minute information, please follow on:


We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing via email. You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us. We will treat your information with respect. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking the Subscribe button, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.
We use MailChimp as our marketing automation platform. By clicking above to submit this form, you acknowledge that the information you provide will be transferred to MailChimp for processing in accordance with their Privacy Policy and Terms.